The Deer Baiting Guide: All About Baiting Whitetails

0
213
Video baiting deer with corn

Baiting whitetails is a popular strategy for many deer hunters across the country. Luring game animals to bait is an age-old hunting technique, with plenty of evidence to show that it was used by Native Americans and other early hunters. These days, baiting deer stirs up a lot of controversy, and in many states it’s entirely illegal. We’re not here to settle the score on the bait debate, but we will arm you with the knowledge to decide if deer baiting is right for you.

For those hoping to learn more about baiting deer, our comprehensive guide will get you on the right track:

  1. Various Uses of Deer Bait
  2. Best Tactics for Baiting Deer
  3. Best Types of Bait for Deer
  4. Alternative Types of Deer Bait or Attractants
  5. State Laws on Baiting Deer
  6. Arguments for Baiting Deer
  7. Arguments Against Baiting Deer
  8. Subscriber Discounts on Deer Gear

Various Uses of Deer Bait

Bait can serve many different purposes. From hunting to supplemental dietary benefits, bait can accomplish numerous goals.

Full-Scale Feeding Programs: Managers of large land tracts oftentimes implement intense feeding programs. They establish feed stations in strategic locations to feed corn, protein, minerals, and more. It’s appropriately used as a dietary supplement to boost herd health.

Attracting and Holding Deer (Out of Sight of Hunting Spots): A common tactic in the East is the use of bait out of sight or outside a specified distance from a hunting location. Some states allow baiting throughout hunting seasons, but sometimes you must maintain a minimum distance from the bait site while hunting. Doing this in the center of the property is usually the best option. When there are legal implications, it’s important to know for certain how far away you are from bait. Use the HuntStand distance measurement tool or a laser rangefinder to verify compliance. If baiting law states that you must be “out of sight” from a bat site, don’t forget to take into account foliage die-off (fall leaf drop) when planning your baits and hunting setups.

Attracting and Holding Deer (Hunting Over or Within Sight of It): Less than half of states permit the use of bait. Even fewer allow it within sight of a hunting spot. However, where permitted, it abounds. Some states permit it under certain restrictions, such as regulating volume of bait. Others pose no limits.

Taking Inventory: A lot of deer hunters and property managers take inventory of their deer herds using bait. This commonly takes place during the pre-season or post-season. Even in states where hunting over bait isn’t permitted, some permit the use of it for scouting.

In many cases, bait must be removed a certain number of days prior to the season, or prior to hunting. That said, the bait must be completely removed. Land managers who run the risk of bait remnants still being in the area, or bait seeping into the soil, might find themselves in a sticky situation. Some wildlife agencies go as far as to test that soil to ensure no attractants remain. For those in such states, perhaps consider feeding bait or mineral in a trough that can be removed.

Best Tactics for Baiting Deer

For those who choose to bait deer in a responsible manner, it isn’t a simple tactic to use. Baiting whitetails isn’t as easy as some might claim. Dumping corn out just anywhere, or anyhow, isn’t in and of itself going to pull a mature buck out in daylight. Oftentimes, mature whitetails go on high alert around bait piles, especially in areas where baiting is frequently (and carelessly) implemented.

Mature whitetails sometimes even go out of their way to avoid bait piles. Bucks with different personalities express different tendencies. Some are more or less likely to hit baited areas, especially during daylight.

Baiting deer needs to be done thoughtfully and strategically. The difficult part is placement. Hunters must position bait in places where mature deer feel comfortable in daylight. Therein lies the challenge, which includes getting close enough to a buck’s bed to place bait without him detecting you.

See also  The Top 5 Fish Finder Options to Consider for Your Boat

While it’s easy to have a “buck first” mentality, also consider the implications of running baits during the rut. As the rut comes into full swing, attracting and keeping tabs on does is perhaps even more important than focusing on bucks. It’s the rut: where there are does, the bucks will follow.

Overall, it’s very difficult to “force” a deer to do something during daylight that it doesn’t already want to do. So, for those who do use bait, it’s important to improve baiting effectiveness. Fortunately, there are numerous ways to do this:

  • Place bait in locations where deer already travel (preferably transition zones or staging areas).
  • If possible, place bait close enough to bedding areas that those deer will hopefully emerge during daylight.
  • Place bait in a manner that allows you to slip into a nearby stand location without alerting nearby deer.
  • Think about how deer might circle downwind before committing to baited areas.
  • Use blockers such as bluffs and rivers to keep deer from circling downwind.
  • Deploy quality feeders that can make bait last longer.
  • Distribute bait in such a manner that minimizes the number of human visits and time spent there.
  • Monitor bait sites with reliable cellular trail cameras to determine how deer are approaching.
  • In unpressured areas, consider hunting over bait from primary treestand locations that are within sight of baited areas.
  • In most situations, consider hunting away from bait stations. Bucks will likely circle downwind of baited areas and won’t approach until after dark.
  • Broadcast bait in a manner that decreases health risks for deer.
  • Never introduce bait suddenly, especially in winter. Introduce it gradually in fall (regulations depending).
Best Trail Camera Locations by Month for Scouting Big Deer

Best Types of Bait for Deer

Deer bait is used in many different forms and formats throughout the nation. Geographical location can play a role in the bait types used, based largely on sources and availability. That said, here are some of the best and most popular deer baits:

  • Acorns
  • Apples
  • Attractants
  • Corn (eared)
  • Corn (shelled)
  • Peanut butter
  • Salt
  • Sugar beets
  • Trace mineral
  • Vegetables

Alternative Types of Deer Bait or Attractants

Do you hunt in a state where baiting isn’t allowed? Or maybe you just don’t want to use bait at all? No worries, there are alternative methods for luring bucks without bait:

  • Bedding cover
  • Calling
  • Decoying
  • Fertilizing ground
  • Food plots
  • Funnels and pinch points
  • Mineral sites
  • Mineral stumps
  • Mock scrapes
  • Natural scrapes
  • Rubbing posts
  • Scents
  • Water holes

States Laws on Baiting Deer

What’s the simple legal definition of baiting? Bait: Food, or some substitute, used as a lure in hunting, fishing, trapping, etc. This includes corn, pelleted feed, mineral or any other type of edible substance.

Just like most other aspects of wildlife management, deer baiting laws vary from state to state. Baiting laws can be black and white, but some state deer baiting laws are quite “gray” or vague. This can leave things up for interpretation. In these instances, it’s especially important to speak with local conservation officers to get their interpretations of the law. Furthermore, if the laws are so gray that they could seemingly be manipulated, perhaps it’s best to avoid baiting altogether.

Some states that allow deer baiting do so with certain provisions. Common restrictions include zone or county restrictions; the amount of bait allowed out at once; how close to the bait you can hunt; times you can and can’t bait deer; types of bait that are permitted, and more. In fact, it’s quite rare for a state to allow baiting without regard to at least a short list of stipulations. To that point, although some states might appear on the “legal” list below, it’s extremely important to pay attention to nuances within any individual state by consulting the regulations.

States that (sometimes) permit baiting on private lands (in at least some capacity) include:

  • Alabama (permit required, distance restrictions)
  • Arkansas (condition and zone restrictions)
  • Connecticut (condition and zone restrictions)
  • Delaware (minimal restrictions)
  • Florida (conditions and restrictions)
  • Georgia (county and distance restrictions)
  • Kansas (minimal restrictions)
  • Kentucky (conditions and zone restrictions)
  • Louisiana (restrictions apply)
  • Maryland (zone restrictions)
  • Michigan (location and volume restrictions)
  • Mississippi (restrictions apply)
  • New Hampshire (permit required, restrictions)
  • New Jersey (zone and distance conditions)
  • North Carolina (allowed outside of bear season zones)
  • North Dakota (zone restrictions)
  • Ohio (zone restrictions)
  • Oklahoma (conditions apply)
  • Oregon (restrictions apply)
  • Pennsylvania (only in a select few southeastern counties)
  • South Carolina (permitted in certain areas)
  • Texas (minimal restrictions)
  • Utah (no state agency information provided)
  • West Virginia (certain counties only)
  • Wisconsin (certain counties only)
  • Wyoming (disabled people only)
See also  Lessons of Geese and Men in a Morning Field
Scouting and Installing Water Sources for Deer

In contrast, some states all-out ban the use of bait. These states completely ban the use of bait in any form, under all circumstances:

  • Arizona
  • California
  • Colorado
  • Idaho
  • Illinois
  • Indiana
  • Iowa
  • Maine
  • Massachusetts
  • Minnesota
  • Missouri
  • Montana
  • Nebraska
  • Nevada
  • New Mexico
  • New York
  • Rhode Island
  • South Dakota
  • Tennessee
  • Vermont
  • Virginia
  • Washington

Disclaimer: This content shouldn’t be considered legal advice. Check your state’s regulations on baiting deer. Baiting laws are very nuanced and detailed and can be different even within the same county. Furthermore, baiting laws frequently change, and it’s important to stay current. HuntStand isn’t liable for incorrect or outdated information. Consult state hunting regulations for information. When in doubt, contact a local conservation officer with questions.

Arguments for Baiting Deer

There are numerous arguments for baiting. In some places, bait is cultural. It’s completely engrained in the very fabric of deer hunting. “These deer are on almost a 100-percent browse diet,” said Texas-based hunting TV show host Mike Stroff. “There are few crops. Baiting is our food plot. Where a guy in the Midwest spends all summer working the dirt, fertilizing it, getting it just right and planting it, we can’t do that here unless you have a way to irrigate it. Corn and protein feed are our food plots.”

How you choose to bait might be different than other hunters. Placing bait in a pile can be considered unhealthy in certain situations, so some hunters prefer to broadcast bait out over a larger areas. In those cases, an ATV spreader works well to broadcast bait over a food-plot-sized area. In this manner, it becomes more of a food plot, rather than a bait “pile.” It keeps deer more spread out, which reduces stress on the herd and the risk of spreading disease.

Although renowned bowhunter Bill Winke hunts mostly in Iowa where he can’t bait deer, he recognizes that, where legal, it can increase the odds in hard-to-hunt terrain types. “Since they stick to cover when traveling, fence lines and narrow necks of timber become obvious choices,” said Winke. “Once the crops are harvested, the deer are restricted to a small number of places they will travel, and those places are easy to find. I feel that, in other regions where deer have more bedding options, you must be more aggressive with strategies like drives, calling, and maybe even baiting.”

Questions Food Plotters Need Answers To

Used properly, bait can be implemented for positive purposes. For instance, in areas where disease concerns are low-risk, it can serve as a dietary supplement to the deer herd. In areas where the soil and plant life lack vital minerals and vitamins, this can offer unmet needs.

Furthermore, hunters can use it to take inventory. This allows land managers to know the bucks on the landscape, and potentially target the oldest ones in the herd. Baiting can be an essential deer management tool.

In an age where hunter numbers are declining, bait can be used to increase deer sightings, which helps newer and younger hunters remain engaged during the hunt. Also, come time to take the shot, bait can help pose an animal for a shot opportunity. This can make the shot process more ethical, especially for new and inexperienced hunters.

See also  Best Compound Bow Reviews for the Money in 2016

Finally, in states where it’s legal, you almost have to bet the neighbors are running bait stations. If you aren’t, the odds of killing a deer can drop significantly. Even those who don’t like to bait might consider it if their neighbors are doing it.

Arguments Against Baiting Deer

Done in an irresponsible manner, feeding whitetails can have negative effects. In concentrated locations, it can increase the chance of spreading diseases and parasites. It can also increase stress levels amongst deer, especially congregating them in such tight areas.

“As a wildlife and deer specialist, I do not recommend artificially feeding deer,” said Lloyd Fox, big-game program coordinator for the Kansas Wildlife, Parks & Tourism. “Here in Kansas, we have tremendous habitat and high-fertility soil.”

Worrisome diseases, such as chronic wasting disease (CWD), are potentially more likely to spread faster wherever deer congregate. But science hasn’t proven if bait is a significant vector for CWD spread, or if banning it is merely a knee-jerk reaction to its presence.

After all, deer are very social animals. There are far more scrapes on the landscape than bait piles, and any communicable disease that a deer can get via saliva or urine around a bait pile is certain to be prevalent in scrapes. In fact, according to the National Deer Association (NDA), recent research by Miranda Huang of the Mississippi State University Deer Lab, proved that to be true. Of 99 scrapes sampled in a Tennessee-based CWD zone, 54 (55 percent) of these tested positive for CWD prions. Interestingly, 35 percent of scrapes have prions on the licking branch only, 14 percent in the soil only, and 6 percent on both the licking branch and in the soil.

How to Find Killer Deer Hunting Funnels

Even so, most deer biologists take stances against deer bait. “It would be a rare instance where feeding deer would be beneficial,” said Tom Micetich, wildlife biologist for the Illinois Department of Natural Resources. “The risks of congregating deer in one place heavily outweigh benefits gained from feeding deer.”

Digestion can be another problem. If a whitetail doesn’t have the appropriate enzymes in its stomach at the time of consumption, certain food sources can’t be digested. This occurs when a deer suddenly switches over to a different food source and consumes a lot of it in a short time. Deer have a specific combination of enzymes and microorganisms in their digestive tracts to help digest natural wintertime food sources. Suddenly feeding mass amounts of corn can be disastrous.

For example, it’s been a hard winter. Hunters suddenly introduce corn to deer where they previously haven’t had access to it. The deer eat the corn. But because the enzymes and microorganisms in their stomachs are specifically designed to digest woody wintertime browse at that point in time, it’s hard to digest the corn. Their digestive systems might acclimate to the sudden dietary change, but it might not. This disruption of dietary enzymes can cause a deer to starve to death, even with a full stomach.

“Deer have been here a long time before us,” said Erik Bartholomew, a deer biologist for the Oklahoma Department of Wildlife Conservation. “Deer are primarily browsers. So, as long as there is enough browse, they’ll be just fine.”

Subscriber Discounts on Deer Gear

We connected with some of our partners to score you discounts on all sorts of gear to support your deer hunting addiction, including some special sauce for your baiting mission.

Use code DEERBAIT23 to stock up and save 20% on deer gear from the following partners. Get everything you need before the rut heats up, this limited-time offer expires September 30th.

  • Boss Buck – Save 20% on feeders, bait, attractants, and more.
  • Stealth Cam – Save 20% on trail cameras and trail camera accessories.
  • Muddy – Save 20% on treestands, ground blinds, trail cameras, and more. (Excludes box blinds.)
50 Best Deer Hunting Excuses to Use This Season
Previous article5 Ways to Catch Early Season Smallmouth Bass
Next articleHow to Skip A Baitcaster Like A Pro
Ethan Smith is a seasoned marine veteran, professional blogger, witty and edgy writer, and an avid hunter. He spent a great deal of his childhood years around the Apache-Sitgreaves National Forest in Arizona. Watching active hunters practise their craft initiated him into the world of hunting and rubrics of outdoor life. He also honed his writing skills by sharing his outdoor experiences with fellow schoolmates through their high school’s magazine. Further along the way, the US Marine Corps got wind of his excellent combination of skills and sought to put them into good use by employing him as a combat correspondent. He now shares his income from this prestigious job with his wife and one kid. Read more >>